AUTOREPTBuying, insuring and running a car
LatestCar batteriesTyres: when to replaceDashboard warning lightsWhat's new →
Insurance guide

Car Insurance for New Drivers: Why It Costs So Much and How to Pay Less

A first car insurance quote can be a shock, sometimes costing more than the car itself. The price is not personal: it reflects how often inexperienced drivers crash. The good news is that new drivers have more control over the premium than any other group.

Contents
  1. Why new drivers pay more
  2. Your options for a first policy
  3. Choose a car that is cheap to insure
  4. Discounts worth asking about
  5. Coverage a new driver should understand
  6. Driving habits that keep premiums falling
  7. Sources and further reading
  8. Common questions

Key points

  • The car you choose affects the premium as much as your age.
  • Joining a parent's policy as a listed driver is usually far cheaper than a standalone policy.
  • Good-student, driver-training and telematics discounts can cut costs meaningfully.
  • Never 'front' a policy by naming a parent as the main driver of your car; it can void cover.

Why new drivers pay more

Insurers price risk using claims data. Drivers in their first few years on the road, and especially teenagers, are involved in crashes at much higher rates than experienced drivers, mainly because of inexperience, speed, distraction and night driving. In the United States, the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety reports that the crash rate per mile driven for 16 to 19 year olds is several times that of drivers aged 20 and over. Insurers translate that into premiums, and the price usually falls steadily with each claim-free year.

Age is not the only factor. Insurers also consider where you live and park, how far you drive, the car's repair costs and safety record, your driving record and, in many US states, a credit-based insurance score. Some states restrict or ban the use of certain factors, such as credit, gender or occupation.

Your options for a first policy

Option How it works Typical effect on cost
Listed driver on a parent's policy You are added as an occasional or principal driver of a household car Usually the cheapest route, though the household premium rises
Your own policy You hold the policy in your name for your own car Often the most expensive at first, but builds your own record
Named on a partner's or employer's policy Similar to a parent's policy, if the insurer allows it Varies widely by insurer
Non-owner policy Liability cover for people who drive but do not own a car Can be useful for occasional drivers

Be honest about who drives the car most. Listing a parent as the main driver of a car that you actually drive every day is called fronting, and an insurer can refuse claims or cancel the policy if it finds out.



Choose a car that is cheap to insure

Insurers group cars by how much they cost to repair, how often they are stolen, how powerful they are and how well they protect occupants. A modest, mainstream car with good crash-test results and plenty of affordable parts is usually far cheaper to insure than a powerful or premium model, even if the purchase prices are similar.

  • Get insurance quotes on two or three specific cars before you buy.
  • Favour modest engines and trims; sporty versions of the same model often cost more to insure.
  • Look for strong ratings from crash-test programs such as IIHS and NHTSA in the US, or Euro NCAP in Europe.
  • Check whether the car has active safety features such as automatic emergency braking.
  • Avoid models with high theft rates in your area.

Our pick of reliable used cars includes several models that tend to be inexpensive to insure.

Discounts worth asking about

Discount Who it helps What to provide
Good student Full-time students with strong grades (often a B average or better) A recent report card or transcript
Driver training Drivers who complete an approved course A completion certificate
Student away at school Students who live far from home without a car Proof of school address and distance
Multi-car and multi-policy Households insuring several cars or bundling home and auto Details of the other policies
Telematics Careful drivers willing to be monitored An app or plug-in device that records driving
Pay in full and paperless Most policyholders Payment upfront and an email address

Telematics, sometimes called usage-based insurance, rewards smooth braking, sensible speeds, limited night driving and fewer miles. It can work well for careful new drivers. Read how the data is used and whether bad driving can raise your price as well as lower it.

Coverage a new driver should understand

Liability coverage pays for injuries and damage you cause to others, and every US state except New Hampshire requires it in some form. State minimums are often low compared with the cost of a serious crash, so many advisers suggest higher limits if you can afford them. Collision covers damage to your own car in a crash, and comprehensive covers theft, fire, flood, hail and vandalism. If your car is financed, the lender will usually require both.

A higher deductible lowers your premium, but choose one you could actually pay after an accident. For a low-value older car, it may make sense to drop collision cover and keep strong liability limits. Our guide to the cheapest auto insurance explains how to compare quotes like for like.

Driving habits that keep premiums falling

  1. Avoid claims and tickets for the first few years; each clean year usually lowers your price at renewal.
  2. Limit night driving and passengers in the first months, which also matches many US graduated licensing rules.
  3. Put the phone out of reach while driving.
  4. Keep your mileage honest and low if you can.
  5. Shop around at every renewal, because the insurer that was cheapest at 17 may not be at 19.

Sources and further reading

  • The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (iihs.org) publishes teen driver crash data and vehicle safety ratings.
  • NHTSA (nhtsa.gov) publishes star safety ratings and recall information for US vehicles.
  • Your state insurance department explains minimum coverage requirements and handles complaints.
  • The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (content.naic.org) has consumer guides to auto insurance.

Common questions

At what age does car insurance get cheaper?

Premiums usually fall with each claim-free year of experience, with notable drops in the early twenties and again around 25. The exact pattern varies by insurer and state.

Is it cheaper to buy a new or used car as a new driver?

An older, modest car often costs less to insure, and you may choose to drop collision cover. Make sure it has good safety ratings.

Will a speeding ticket raise my premium?

Usually, yes, often for three years or more. A serious violation can raise it sharply or make you high-risk.

Can I insure a car I do not own?

Yes, through a non-owner policy or by being listed on the owner's policy, depending on how often you drive it.

This guide is general information, not personal financial, legal or insurance advice. Insurance and lending rules vary by state and country, and policies differ, so check the terms of any offer and speak to a licensed professional about your situation.