AUTOREPTBuying, insuring and running a car
LatestCar batteriesTyres: when to replaceDashboard warning lightsWhat's new →
Insurance guide

How to Find the Cheapest Auto Insurance Without Buying Too Little Cover

There is no single cheapest car insurer. The cheapest company for your neighbour may be one of the most expensive for you, because every insurer weighs risk differently. The way to find a low price is a method, not a brand.

Contents
  1. Why prices vary so much between insurers
  2. Compare like for like
  3. The factors you can change
  4. The deductible decision, with numbers
  5. Discounts that are worth chasing
  6. Cuts that are not worth the saving
  7. A repeatable shopping routine
  8. Sources and further reading
  9. Common questions

Key points

  • Compare at least three to five quotes with identical limits and deductibles.
  • Your car, location, mileage and record matter more than the insurer's advertising.
  • Raising the deductible saves money only if you can afford it after an accident.
  • State minimum liability is the cheapest option and often the riskiest.

Why prices vary so much between insurers

Each insurer uses its own rating model and its own claims experience. One company may be keen to win young drivers in your city; another may have had heavy losses there and priced accordingly. Insurers also change their rates over time. That is why the same driver can receive quotes that differ by hundreds or even thousands a year, and why loyalty is rarely rewarded on price.

Compare like for like

A cheap quote with half the cover is not a cheap quote. Before you compare, decide on the coverage you want and request exactly that from each insurer.

Item to match Why it matters
Liability limits (for example, 100/300/100) Higher limits protect your savings and income after a serious crash
Uninsured and underinsured motorist cover Protects you if the at-fault driver has little or no insurance
Collision and comprehensive Pay for damage to your own car
Deductibles A different deductible changes the price and your out-of-pocket risk
Extras such as rental car and roadside assistance Small, but they distort comparisons
Named drivers and annual mileage Must be accurate on every quote

Liability limits are often written as three numbers. In 100/300/100, the policy pays up to 100,000 for injuries to one person, 300,000 for all injuries in one crash, and 100,000 for property damage.

The factors you can change

  • The car: modest, safe, cheap-to-repair cars cost less to insure.
  • The deductible: a higher deductible lowers the premium.
  • Mileage: some insurers price heavily on how far you drive; pay-per-mile policies exist for low-mileage drivers.
  • Where the car is kept: a garage or driveway can help in some areas.
  • Your record: avoiding claims and violations has the biggest long-term effect.
  • Payment method: paying the full term upfront often avoids instalment fees.
  • Credit-based insurance score: in states that allow it, improving credit can lower premiums over time.

The deductible decision, with numbers

Suppose raising your collision and comprehensive deductible from 500 to 1,000 saves 180 a year. You are accepting an extra 500 of risk on each claim in exchange for 180 a year. If you claim less than once every two to three years, the higher deductible probably comes out ahead.

With a 500 deductible you pay 180 more each year. Over three claim-free years that is 540, more than the extra 500 you would pay on a single claim. If you had a claim in year one, you would be 320 worse off that year, but still ahead by the end of year three.

Only choose a deductible you can pay from savings tomorrow. If an accident would force you to borrow, the lower deductible is worth its price.

Discounts that are worth chasing

  • Bundling auto with renters or home insurance.
  • Insuring several cars with one company.
  • Safe-driver, claim-free and defensive-driving course discounts.
  • Good-student and student-away discounts.
  • Anti-theft devices and certain safety features.
  • Paperless, automatic payment and pay-in-full discounts.
  • Telematics programs that reward smooth, daytime, low-mileage driving.

Check the final price after discounts rather than the number of discounts, because an insurer with fewer discounts can still be cheaper overall.

Cuts that are not worth the saving

Tempting cut The risk
Buying only the state minimum liability A serious crash can exceed minimum limits quickly, leaving you personally liable
Dropping uninsured motorist cover You could be left paying for your own injuries if the other driver is uninsured
Dropping comprehensive on a valuable car Theft, flood or hail would be entirely your cost
Leaving off a regular driver Claims can be refused and the policy cancelled
Understating your mileage or garaging address This is misrepresentation, which can void cover

A repeatable shopping routine

  1. Write down your current coverage, limits and deductibles from your declarations page.
  2. Decide whether you want to change any of them.
  3. Get quotes from a mix of large national insurers, regional insurers and an independent agent who can compare several companies.
  4. Check each insurer's financial strength and complaint record with your state insurance department.
  5. Switch only after the new policy is active, so that you are never uninsured.
  6. Set a reminder to repeat the process a month before each renewal.


Sources and further reading

  • The NAIC (content.naic.org) publishes consumer guides and complaint data for insurers.
  • Your state insurance department lists licensed insurers and minimum coverage rules.
  • The Insurance Information Institute (iii.org) explains how premiums are calculated.

Common questions

How often should I shop for car insurance?

At least once a year before renewal, and after any big change such as moving, buying a car, marriage or a change in commute.

Does checking quotes hurt my credit?

Insurance quotes typically use a soft inquiry, which does not affect your credit score.

Is pay-per-mile insurance cheaper?

It can be for people who drive very little. If you drive average or above-average miles, a standard policy is usually cheaper.

Can I cancel my policy mid-term?

Usually yes, and you will normally receive a refund for the unused portion, though some insurers charge a fee.

This guide is general information, not personal financial, legal or insurance advice. Insurance and lending rules vary by state and country, and policies differ, so check the terms of any offer and speak to a licensed professional about your situation.