AUTOREPTBuying, insuring and running a car
LatestCar batteriesTyres: when to replaceDashboard warning lightsWhat's new →
Buying guide

Lease vs Buy: How to Compare the Real Cost Over the Same Period

A lease payment is almost always lower than a loan payment on the same car, which makes leasing look cheaper. It often is not. The fair comparison is what each option costs you over the same number of months, after counting what you own at the end.

Contents
  1. How a lease payment is built
  2. Compare the two fairly
  3. When leasing makes sense
  4. When buying makes sense
  5. Fees and limits to read before you sign
  6. The long-run view
  7. Sources and further reading
  8. Common questions

Key points

  • A lease payment pays for the car's expected loss in value during the lease, plus a finance charge set by the money factor.
  • To compare fairly, count the cash you pay over the lease period for each option, then subtract the value of the car you own at the end if you buy.
  • The negotiable parts of a lease are the price of the car (the capitalised cost), the money factor and some fees. The residual value is usually set by the leasing company.
  • Leasing suits drivers who want a new car every few years, drive predictable, moderate mileage and keep cars in good condition.
  • Buying and keeping a car well beyond the loan is usually the cheapest way to drive over the long run.

How a lease payment is built

A lease has four main numbers. They appear on the lease disclosure form, and you should ask for each one.

Term Meaning
Capitalised cost The price of the car in the lease, plus any fees rolled in. This is negotiable.
Capitalised cost reduction Any down payment, trade-in equity or rebate that lowers the capitalised cost.
Residual value What the leasing company expects the car to be worth at the end, usually a percentage of the list price.
Money factor The finance charge, written as a small decimal such as 0.0025. Multiply by 2,400 to get an approximate APR; 0.0025 is about 6%.

The monthly payment, before tax, is two parts added together:

  • Depreciation charge = (capitalised cost − reduction − residual value) ÷ number of months
  • Rent charge = (capitalised cost − reduction + residual value) × money factor

The depreciation charge is the important one. You are paying for the slice of the car's value you use up. A car with a high residual value, one expected to hold its value well, has a lower lease payment.

A 35,000 car on a 36-month lease with a 58% residual (20,300), a money factor of 0.0025 and a 2,000 down payment:

  • Depreciation charge: (35,000 − 2,000 − 20,300) ÷ 36 = about 353
  • Rent charge: (33,000 + 20,300) × 0.0025 = about 133
  • Payment before tax: about 486 a month

Over three years, with about 1,000 in acquisition and disposition fees, the lease costs about 20,500 in total, and you hand the car back.

Compare the two fairly

Buying the same car with 2,000 down and a 60-month loan at 6.5% means a payment of about 646. That looks far worse. But after 36 months you have paid about 25,240 in total, you still owe about 14,500, and you own a car worth around 20,300. Selling it and clearing the loan would leave a net cost of about 19,440, slightly less than leasing in this example.

The calculator runs that comparison with your own figures. It assumes the car is worth the residual value at the end of the lease, which is the leasing company's own estimate.

Lease vs buy calculator
Lease payment (before tax)-
Total cost of leasing-
Net cost of buying, same period-
Difference-

Estimate only. Excludes sales tax, which is charged differently on leases and purchases from state to state, and insurance, which is often higher on a lease because of required limits. A positive difference means buying costs less over the lease period.

When leasing makes sense

  • You want a new car every two to four years and would otherwise trade in early, absorbing the steepest depreciation anyway.
  • You drive a predictable, moderate number of miles a year, inside the lease limit.
  • The manufacturer is offering a subsidised lease, with a high residual value or a low money factor, to move a particular model.
  • You use the car for business and your accountant confirms lease payments are treated favourably for you.
  • You want a car always under warranty, with predictable costs.

When buying makes sense

  • You keep cars for many years. Every year after the loan is paid off is a year of driving with no payment.
  • You drive a lot of miles, or your mileage is unpredictable.
  • You want to modify the car, or you have children or pets who make excess wear charges likely.
  • You prefer to own the car outright and not deal with an inspection at the end.

Fees and limits to read before you sign

Item What to check
Acquisition fee Charged at the start by the leasing company. Sometimes rolled into the capitalised cost.
Disposition fee Charged when you return the car, often waived if you lease another from the same brand.
Mileage allowance Commonly 10,000 to 15,000 miles a year. Buying extra miles up front is cheaper than the penalty at the end.
Excess wear Read the wear-and-tear guide. Tyres, kerbed wheels, windscreen chips and interior stains are common charges.
Early termination How the payoff is calculated if you end the lease early.
Purchase option The price to buy the car at the end, usually the residual value plus a fee.
Gap protection Many leases include it. Check before buying it separately.

The long-run view

Leasing means you are always paying for the steepest part of a car's depreciation. Buying and keeping a reliable car for eight or ten years spreads that early loss across many more months, which is why, over a lifetime of driving, it is usually the cheapest pattern. Our total cost of ownership calculator shows the effect of keeping a car longer.

Sources and further reading

  • The Federal Reserve Board's consumer guide to vehicle leasing and the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau's resources on auto leases.
  • The lease disclosure form required under the US Consumer Leasing Act, which lists the capitalised cost, residual value, rent charge and fees.
  • The leasing company's published residual values and money factors, which dealers can show you on request.

Common questions

Can I negotiate a lease?

Yes. Negotiate the price of the car exactly as if you were buying it, because that becomes the capitalised cost. Ask for the base money factor the leasing company offers for your credit tier, since dealers can mark it up. Residual values are usually fixed by the leasing company.

What happens if I go over the mileage limit?

You pay a charge for every mile over the limit when you return the car, often 15 to 30 cents a mile. If you know you will drive more, buy extra miles at the start, which is usually cheaper than paying the penalty at the end.

Can I end a lease early?

Usually, but it is often expensive, because you owe the remaining depreciation and fees. Options include buying the car, selling it to a dealer who pays off the lease, or a lease transfer if the leasing company allows it.

Should I put a large down payment on a lease?

Usually not. A down payment on a lease, called a capitalised cost reduction, lowers the monthly payment but is lost if the car is stolen or written off early, because gap protection typically pays the leasing company, not you. Keep it small.

This guide is general information, not personal financial, legal, insurance or mechanical advice. Rules, prices and specifications vary by state, country and vehicle, so check the details that apply to you and speak to a qualified professional about your situation.

Your next step

Negotiate the price first

Whether you lease or buy, the price of the car drives everything else. Our out-the-door guide shows how to total and negotiate it.

Read the negotiation guide