AUTOREPTBuying, insuring and running a car
LatestCar batteriesTyres: when to replaceDashboard warning lightsWhat's new →
Insurance guide

What to Do After a Car Accident: The Scene, the Claim and the Payout, Step by Step

The minutes after a crash are stressful, and the weeks after it are full of forms. Most of the money and stress in a claim is decided by a few things you do early: what you record at the scene, which insurer you claim through, and whether you check the adjuster's numbers.

Contents
  1. At the scene
  2. In the first 24 hours
  3. Which insurer to claim through
  4. How the adjuster decides: repair or total loss
  5. Checking a total loss offer
  6. Rental cars and getting around
  7. After the claim
  8. Sources and further reading
  9. Common questions

Key points

  • Safety first: move to safety if you can, call emergency services if anyone is hurt, and turn on hazard lights.
  • Record everything at the scene: the other driver's details, insurance, plates, photos and witnesses. Do not argue about fault.
  • Report the accident to your insurer promptly, even if you think the other driver will pay. Late notice can complicate a claim.
  • If the car is a total loss, the payout is its actual cash value. You can challenge a low valuation with comparable listings.
  • Keep a single claim log with every call, name, date and document.

At the scene

The order matters. Your safety and other people's comes before the paperwork.

  1. 01
    Stop and make it safeStop as soon as it is safe. Turn on hazard lights. If the cars can be driven and no one is hurt, move them out of traffic if your state allows it. Leaving the scene of an accident is a crime almost everywhere.
  2. 02
    Check for injuries and call for helpCall emergency services if anyone is hurt, if a car cannot be moved, or if the other driver seems impaired or leaves. Do not move someone who may have a neck or back injury unless there is immediate danger.
  3. 03
    Exchange detailsName, phone, address, driving licence number, insurer and policy number, and the make, model, colour and plate of every vehicle. Photograph the other driver's licence and insurance card if they agree.
  4. 04
    Photograph everythingAll four sides of each car, close-ups of damage, the plates, the road layout, skid marks, signs and signals, the weather and any debris. Take a wide shot that shows where the cars ended up.
  5. 05
    Find witnessesAsk anyone who saw the crash for their name and number. A neutral witness can settle a dispute about fault.
  6. 06
    Stay calm about faultBe polite and factual. Do not argue about who caused the accident or agree to pay for damage on the spot. Fault is decided later from the evidence.
  7. 07
    Get the police report numberIf police attend, note the officers' names and the report number. You will need it for the claim.

Keep a pen and a printed copy of this list in the glovebox. Under stress, a checklist works better than memory.

In the first 24 hours

  • See a doctor if you feel any pain. Some injuries, such as whiplash, appear hours or days later. A prompt medical record also supports an injury claim.
  • Report the accident to your insurer. Most policies require "prompt" notice. Do it even if you believe the other driver is at fault and will pay. Many insurers let you start online or in an app.
  • Check whether you must report to the state. Many states require a report to the motor vehicle agency when there are injuries or damage above a threshold, sometimes within a few days, even if police attended.
  • Start a claim log. One document or notebook with every call, the person you spoke to, the date and what was agreed. Save every email and photo in one folder.

Which insurer to claim through

You usually have two routes:

Route When to use it Pros Cons
The other driver's insurer (third-party claim) The other driver is clearly at fault and insured No deductible to pay; claim does not count as at-fault on your record You are not their customer; they may dispute fault or move slowly
Your own insurer (first-party claim) under collision Fault is disputed, the other driver is uninsured, or you want repairs to start quickly Your insurer works for you under your contract; often faster You pay your deductible up front; your insurer may recover it later from the other insurer (subrogation)

If you go through your own insurer and the other driver is found at fault, your insurer may pursue their insurer and refund your deductible. Ask your adjuster to tell you when that happens.

In no-fault states, your own personal injury protection pays your medical costs first, whoever caused the accident. Car damage is still usually handled on a fault basis.

How the adjuster decides: repair or total loss

An adjuster, or a photo-estimating system, will inspect the damage and produce an estimate. Then one of two things happens.

Repair. The insurer pays the repair cost, minus your deductible on a first-party claim. Repair shops often find more damage once they take panels off; they file a "supplement" with the insurer for the extra work, which is normal.

Total loss. If repairs would cost more than a set share of the car's value, the insurer declares it a total loss and pays its actual cash value instead. Many states set a threshold by law, often somewhere between 60% and 100% of the car's value; other states use a formula that also counts the car's salvage value.

Your car's actual cash value is 9,000 and the repair estimate is 7,200. In a state with a 75% total-loss threshold, the limit is 6,750, so the car is written off. You receive 9,000 minus your deductible, plus, in many states, a share of sales tax and registration fees for a replacement. If you still owe 11,000 on the loan, you are 2,000 short unless you have gap insurance.

Checking a total loss offer

Insurers use valuation reports based on similar cars sold or listed in your area. These reports can be wrong. Before you accept:

  1. Ask for the full valuation report, including the comparable vehicles used.
  2. Check the details. Is the trim level, engine, mileage and option list right? A missing option or wrong trim can cut the value.
  3. Find your own comparables. Collect three to five listings for the same model, year, trim and similar mileage near you. Save screenshots with dates.
  4. Add recent work. New tyres, a new battery or major recent repairs can justify a higher value. Send receipts.
  5. Make a written counter-offer with your evidence, and ask the adjuster to explain any difference.
  6. Use the appraisal clause if needed. Many policies let each side hire an independent appraiser, with an umpire to settle any disagreement. Your state insurance department can also take a complaint about claim handling.

Rental cars and getting around

Rental costs are paid by the at-fault driver's insurer while your car is being repaired or until a total-loss offer is made, usually for a "reasonable" period. On your own policy, rental is paid only if you bought rental reimbursement cover, and only up to its daily and total limits. Ask early how many days are approved, and return the rental promptly once the repairs are done or a settlement is offered.

After the claim

  • Check the repairs before you sign off: panel gaps, paint match, warning lights, and that everything works.
  • Keep the paperwork for as long as you own the car. Buyers and future insurers may ask about it.
  • Review your premium at renewal. An at-fault claim usually affects your price for several years. Note the date it should stop counting, and requote then. Our guide to how premiums are calculated explains why.

Sources and further reading

  • Your state's motor vehicle agency, for when an accident must be reported and the forms to use.
  • Your state insurance department, for claim-handling rules, appraisal rights and complaint procedures.
  • The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration's crash safety guidance at nhtsa.gov.
  • Your policy wording, especially the sections on duties after a loss, appraisal, rental reimbursement and total loss settlement.

Common questions

Should I file a claim for a small accident?

If no one was hurt and the damage is small, you may choose to pay yourself to avoid a claim on your record, but you should still tell your insurer about the accident as your policy requires. Reporting an accident is not always the same as filing a claim; ask your insurer how it treats each. Injuries can appear days later, so be cautious about settling privately with the other driver.

Do I have to use the insurer's preferred repair shop?

In most US states you have the right to choose your own repair shop. The insurer's network shop may offer a guarantee and faster payment, but you are generally not required to use it.

What if the other driver has no insurance?

Claim through your own uninsured motorist cover for injuries and, in some states, for car damage, or through your collision cover, which will charge your deductible. Report the accident to the police; it supports the claim.

What is diminished value?

The loss in resale value a car suffers because it now has an accident history, even after good repairs. Some states allow you to claim it from the at-fault driver's insurer. It is rarely paid on your own policy.

This guide is general information, not legal or insurance advice. Accident reporting rules, fault systems and claim rights vary by state and country. After any accident with injuries or a dispute over fault, consider speaking to a licensed attorney or your state insurance department.

Your next step

Check your cover before you need it

Most claim surprises come from what the policy does not include: low limits, no rental cover or no gap cover on a financed car. Review your declarations page with our 20-minute checklist.

Open the checklist