AUTOREPTBuying, insuring and running a car
LatestCar batteriesTyres: when to replaceDashboard warning lightsWhat's new →
Buying guide

The True Cost of Owning a Car: A Five-Year Budget You Can Fill In Yourself

The price on the windscreen is only the start. Over five years, losing value, interest, insurance and fuel usually cost more than the car's original price suggests. Add them up before you buy, and two cars with the same sticker price can turn out thousands apart.

Contents
  1. The seven costs of owning a car
  2. What the national averages say
  3. Run the numbers
  4. A worked example: two cars, same budget
  5. The four numbers that decide most of the total
  6. Costs people forget
  7. How to use this before you buy
  8. Sources and further reading
  9. Common questions

Key points

  • Depreciation, the value the car loses while you own it, is usually the largest single cost, larger than fuel or insurance.
  • AAA's most recent Your Driving Costs analysis puts the average cost to own and run a new vehicle at about 12,860 dollars a year.
  • Comparing cars by cost per month or cost per mile over the whole time you will own them is far more useful than comparing sticker prices.
  • Insurance quotes and fuel economy figures for each car on your shortlist are the quickest way to spot an expensive surprise.

The seven costs of owning a car

Cost What it is How to estimate it
Depreciation The value the car loses while you own it Price paid minus expected value when you sell; pricing guides show typical resale values
Finance charges Interest on the loan, plus any lender fees Total interest from the loan quote or a loan calculator
Insurance Your premium for this specific car Real quotes for each car on your shortlist
Fuel or charging Energy for the miles you drive Miles per year ÷ fuel economy × fuel price
Maintenance and repairs Scheduled servicing plus unplanned repairs Owner's manual schedule, local prices and a repair fund
Tyres Replacement tyres over the period Tyre size and price × number of sets you will need
Taxes and fees Sales tax, registration, title, inspection, parking permits Your state's motor vehicle agency fee schedule

What the national averages say

AAA has published its Your Driving Costs study every year since 1950, averaging popular new models across several vehicle categories. Its most recent edition puts the average cost of owning and running a new vehicle at about 12,860 dollars a year, or roughly 1,070 a month. The previous year's figure was about 11,580, though AAA changed its method between the two editions, so the numbers are not a like-for-like comparison.

The 2025 edition shows how the money is typically split. Depreciation was the largest item, at roughly 4,330 dollars a year. Insurance averaged around 1,690 and finance charges around 1,130, with fuel, maintenance, tyres and fees making up the rest.

Averages are useful as a sense check, but your own figures can be very different. Insurance alone can vary by thousands depending on age, location and record, and fuel costs depend entirely on how far you drive. The calculator below lets you replace each average with your own number.

Run the numbers

Fill in the figures for one car. Then change the price, resale percentage, insurance and fuel to compare a second car on your shortlist.

Total cost of ownership calculator
Total cost over the period-
Of which depreciation-
Cost per month-
Cost per mile-

Estimate only. Assumes the loan is paid off from the sale proceeds if it is still running when you sell. Maintenance usually rises as a car ages, so add more for the later years of an older car.

A worked example: two cars, same budget

Car A is a new compact SUV for 32,000. Car B is a three-year-old version of the same model for 24,000. Both are kept for five years and driven 12,000 miles a year.

  • Depreciation: Car A keeps about 50% of its value after five years and loses about 16,000. Car B, already past its steepest years, might keep about 55% of its purchase price and lose about 10,800.
  • Finance: used-car loans usually carry a higher rate. At 7% for A and 10% for B over 60 months, with 4,000 down, A costs about 5,270 in interest and B about 5,500, slightly more despite the lower price.
  • Insurance: usually somewhat cheaper for the older car, because it is worth less to repair or replace.
  • Maintenance: higher for B, which reaches its larger scheduled services and wear items during your ownership.

Put the figures into the calculator and Car B typically comes out several thousand cheaper over five years, mainly through depreciation. The gap narrows if B needs a major repair, which is why a pre-purchase inspection matters.

The four numbers that decide most of the total

  1. How long you keep the car. Depreciation is steepest in the first years. Keeping a car longer spreads that loss over more months, which is why "buy and hold" is usually the cheapest pattern.
  2. The resale percentage. Models that hold their value well can be cheaper overall than cheaper-to-buy models that do not. Check typical five-year resale values before you choose.
  3. The insurance quote. Get real quotes for each car on your shortlist. Two similar cars can differ by hundreds a year.
  4. The loan term and rate. A longer loan lowers the payment and raises the total. Our auto loan guide explains how to get a fair rate.

Costs people forget

  • Sales tax and dealer fees, which add several percent to the price in most states. Our out-the-door price guide shows how to total them.
  • Tyres, especially on SUVs and performance models with large or low-profile sizes.
  • Parking and tolls, which can exceed fuel in some cities.
  • Home charging equipment for an electric car, and its installation.
  • Inspection and emissions testing in states that require them.
  • A repair fund. Once a car is out of warranty, setting aside a fixed amount each month turns surprise repairs into a planned cost.

How to use this before you buy

Run the calculator for each car on your shortlist with real quotes for insurance and finance. Compare the cost per month with your budget, not just the loan payment. If the cheapest car to buy is not the cheapest to own, the calculator will show you why.

Sources and further reading

  • AAA's annual Your Driving Costs analysis and calculator, at newsroom.aaa.com and aaa.com.
  • The US EPA and Department of Energy's official fuel economy ratings at fueleconomy.gov.
  • Pricing guides such as Kelley Blue Book and Edmunds for expected resale values.
  • Your state motor vehicle agency for registration, title and inspection fees.

Common questions

Is it cheaper to buy new or used?

Over the same number of years, a two- to four-year-old car is usually cheaper to own because the first owner has absorbed the steepest depreciation. Higher repair risk and a higher interest rate on used-car loans narrow the gap, so run both through the calculator.

What is a sensible share of income to spend on a car?

There is no official rule. A common guideline is to keep the total cost of all your cars, including insurance and fuel, to roughly 10 to 15 percent of take-home pay. The calculator's monthly figure is the number to compare.

Why does depreciation count as a cost if I never sell the car?

Because the car is worth less every year whether or not you sell it. If you drive it until it is worth very little, you have used up almost all of its value, which is exactly the cost depreciation measures.

How do I estimate maintenance for a specific car?

Read the maintenance schedule in the owner's manual, price the scheduled services with a local workshop, and add a repair fund that grows with age. Our maintenance schedule guide has typical intervals.

This guide is general information, not personal financial, legal, insurance or mechanical advice. Rules, prices and specifications vary by state, country and vehicle, so check the details that apply to you and speak to a qualified professional about your situation.

Your next step

Compare leasing on the same basis

Once you know the five-year cost of buying, our lease vs buy calculator compares it with leasing over the same period.

Compare lease and buy