AUTOREPTBuying, insuring and running a car
LatestCar batteriesTyres: when to replaceDashboard warning lightsWhat's new →
Buying guide

How to Negotiate a Car's Out-the-Door Price, Line by Line

The out-the-door price is the one number that includes everything: the car, taxes, fees and add-ons. Negotiate that figure, in writing, before you discuss monthly payments, and most of the usual dealership tricks stop working.

Contents
  1. What makes up the out-the-door price
  2. Work out your out-the-door price
  3. Negotiate in this order
  4. Never negotiate the monthly payment
  5. Add-ons and fees to question
  6. Scripts you can use
  7. Before you sign
  8. Sources and further reading
  9. Common questions

Key points

  • Always ask for an itemised out-the-door price in writing. It is the only number that lets you compare dealers fairly.
  • Government taxes and registration fees are not negotiable. The car's price, dealer fees and add-ons are.
  • Negotiate in this order: the price of the car, then your trade-in, then the financing. Never negotiate the monthly payment.
  • Get a loan preapproval before you visit, so the dealer has to beat a real rate.
  • Pre-installed add-ons such as nitrogen tyres, paint protection and window etching are often overpriced. Ask for them to be removed or not charged.

What makes up the out-the-door price

Line What it is Negotiable?
Vehicle price The agreed price of the car itself Yes, this is the main negotiation
Destination charge Shipping from the factory, on new cars, set by the manufacturer Rarely
Dealer documentation fee Paperwork fee charged by the dealer Sometimes; capped or regulated in some states
Dealer add-ons Pre-installed extras and packages added by the dealer Yes, often removable
Sales tax Set by your state and locality No
Title and registration Paid to your state No, but check the amounts against the state's fee schedule
Rebates and incentives Money off from the manufacturer Not negotiable, but make sure every one you qualify for is applied
Trade-in What the dealer pays for your old car Yes, negotiate it separately

Work out your out-the-door price

Use this worksheet with each dealer's quote. In most states, sales tax is charged on the price after the trade-in is deducted, which is what the calculator assumes. Some states, including California, tax the full price before the trade-in, so check your state's rule.

Out-the-door price worksheet
Sales tax-
Out-the-door price-
Left to pay or finance-

Estimate only. Tax treatment of fees, rebates and trade-ins varies by state. If the loan on your trade-in is larger than its value, the shortfall is added to what you pay, which is negative equity.

Negotiate in this order

  1. The price of the car. Agree the out-the-door figure first, as if you were paying cash.
  2. The trade-in. Get offers from online buyers and other dealers first, so you know what your car is worth. Then negotiate the dealer's offer separately.
  3. The financing. Arrive with a preapproval. Ask the dealer to beat its APR for the same term; if they can, take it, and if not, use your own.
  4. The add-ons. Decide in the finance office, with prices in writing. You can decline them.

The reason for this order is that dealers can easily move money between these four areas. A generous trade-in offer can be paid for by a higher car price; a low monthly payment can be paid for by a longer loan. Keeping each conversation separate stops that.

Never negotiate the monthly payment

If a salesperson asks what monthly payment you are looking for, decline to answer. Any payment target can be hit by stretching the loan term or adding to the amount financed. Say you are negotiating the out-the-door price and will arrange financing separately.

A dealer offers to cut your payment from about 540 to about 470 a month. It looks like a 70 discount, but the term has moved from 60 to 72 months. On a 27,000 loan at 7.5%, that change alone adds about 1,150 in interest, and you make payments for an extra year.

Add-ons and fees to question

  • Pre-installed packages such as nitrogen-filled tyres, paint and fabric protection, window etching and wheel locks. These are often added to every car on the lot. Ask for them to be removed or not charged.
  • Market adjustment or "additional dealer markup" on in-demand models. Shop other dealers; many do not charge it.
  • Dealer prep or reconditioning fees on top of the price, especially on new cars.
  • Extended warranties and service contracts. They can be bought later and from other providers. Never accept one without seeing the price, the coverage and the cancellation terms in writing.
  • Gap protection. Useful for some buyers, but usually cheaper from your insurer than from the dealer. See our gap insurance guide.

Scripts you can use

Email to several dealers:

Hello, I'm interested in [year, make, model, trim, colour], stock number [if known]. Please send me your best out-the-door price, itemised to show the vehicle price, every fee, any add-ons, tax and registration for [your town and state]. I have financing arranged and I'm comparing several dealers this week. Thank you.

When an add-on appears on the paperwork:

I didn't agree to this item. Please remove it, or take its cost off the vehicle price so the out-the-door total matches what we agreed.

When pressed for a monthly payment:

I'm only discussing the out-the-door price today. Once we agree that, I'll decide how to pay.

Before you sign

  • Check that the out-the-door total matches the written quote, line by line.
  • Check that the interest rate, term and amount financed match what you agreed.
  • Make sure every rebate is shown and every add-on you declined is gone.
  • Do not sign a contract with blank spaces, and take copies of everything.
  • For a used car, insist on a pre-purchase inspection before you sign, not after.

Sources and further reading

  • The Federal Trade Commission's consumer guidance on buying a new or used car and on dealer add-ons, at consumer.ftc.gov.
  • Your state's motor vehicle agency and department of revenue for sales tax, title and registration fees, and any cap on dealer documentation fees.
  • The Monroney window sticker on new cars, which lists the manufacturer's suggested price, options and destination charge.

Common questions

Is the documentation fee negotiable?

Dealers often say it is fixed, and some states require them to charge every customer the same fee or cap it by law. Even when the fee itself cannot change, you can ask the dealer to take the same amount off the car's price, which has the same effect on the out-the-door total.

Is the destination charge negotiable?

On a new car, the destination charge is set by the manufacturer and listed on the window sticker, so it is not usually negotiable. A separate 'dealer prep' or 'delivery' fee on top of it is a dealer charge and is worth challenging.

Should I tell the dealer I am paying cash?

Settle the price first, before discussing how you will pay. Dealers earn money from arranging finance, so some are less flexible on price for cash buyers. Once the price is agreed in writing, you can choose the dealer's finance if it beats your preapproval.

Can I negotiate by email?

Yes, and it often works well. Email several dealers with the exact car you want and ask for an itemised out-the-door price. You get written quotes to compare and avoid hours at the dealership.

This guide is general information, not personal financial, legal, insurance or mechanical advice. Rules, prices and specifications vary by state, country and vehicle, so check the details that apply to you and speak to a qualified professional about your situation.

Your next step

Line up your financing before you go

A preapproval from a bank or credit union gives you a rate the dealer has to beat. Our auto loan guide shows how to get one.

Read the auto loan guide