AUTOREPTBuying, insuring and running a car
LatestCar batteriesTyres: when to replaceDashboard warning lightsWhat's new →
Insurance guide

Liability vs Full Coverage: When You Can Safely Drop Collision and Comprehensive

As a car ages, the most an insurer will ever pay for it falls every year, but the price of covering it does not fall nearly as fast. At some point you are paying a lot to protect very little. This guide shows how to find that point for your own car.

Contents
  1. What each type of cover pays for
  2. The ceiling on what you can collect
  3. Run the numbers
  4. Four questions before you drop it
  5. A middle path: raise the deductible first
  6. What to keep whatever you decide
  7. When to check again
  8. Sources and further reading
  9. Common questions

Key points

  • "Full coverage" is not a legal term. It usually means liability plus collision and comprehensive.
  • Liability cover protects other people from you. Collision and comprehensive protect your own car, and only up to its actual cash value minus your deductible.
  • If the car is financed or leased, the lender almost always requires collision and comprehensive.
  • When a year of collision and comprehensive costs a large share of what you could ever collect, and you could replace the car from savings, dropping them is worth considering.
  • Never cut liability limits to save money. They protect your savings and income, not the car.

What each type of cover pays for

Coverage Pays for Required?
Bodily injury liability Injuries you cause to other people Required in almost every state
Property damage liability Damage you cause to other people's cars and property Required in almost every state
Uninsured/underinsured motorist Your injuries (and in some states your car) when the at-fault driver has too little or no insurance Required in some states
Personal injury protection or medical payments Medical bills for you and your passengers, whoever is at fault Required in no-fault states
Collision Damage to your car from hitting another car or object, or rolling over Optional, unless your lender requires it
Comprehensive Theft, fire, flood, hail, vandalism, falling objects, animal strikes Optional, unless your lender requires it

"Liability only" means you carry the required covers and no collision or comprehensive. "Full coverage" is a sales term rather than a defined product, but it almost always means liability plus collision and comprehensive. It does not mean you are covered for everything: wear and tear, mechanical breakdown and your own belongings in the car are excluded either way.

The ceiling on what you can collect

Collision and comprehensive pay the cost of repairs, or the car's actual cash value if repairs would cost more than the car is worth. Actual cash value is what the car was worth just before the loss, not what you paid for it. From that you lose your deductible.

So the most you can ever collect in a total loss is:

Maximum payout = actual cash value − deductible

On a newer car that ceiling is high, and the cover is clearly worth having. On a 12-year-old car worth 4,000 with a 1,000 deductible, the most the insurer will ever pay is 3,000, however bad the crash. If those two covers cost 700 a year, you would be paying nearly a quarter of the maximum payout every year to protect it.

Run the numbers

Find the separate premiums for collision and comprehensive on your declarations page and add them together. Then estimate your car's private-party value with a pricing guide.

Should I keep collision and comprehensive?
Most you could collect-
Yearly cost as % of that-
Years of premiums to equal one payout-

Estimate only. A total loss is the largest possible claim; most claims are partial repairs and pay less. The car's value also falls each year, so the maximum payout shrinks over time.

There is no single correct cut-off, but these readings are a reasonable starting point:

  • Under about 10%: the cover is usually good value. Keep it.
  • About 10–20%: it depends on your savings and risk. If replacing the car would be a hardship, keep at least comprehensive.
  • Above about 20%, or fewer than five years to equal one payout: dropping collision, and possibly comprehensive, is worth serious thought.

Four questions before you drop it

  1. Is the car financed or leased? If so, the contract almost certainly requires collision and comprehensive. Dropping them can let the lender buy expensive force-placed insurance and add it to your loan.
  2. Could you replace the car tomorrow from savings? Self-insuring only works if a total loss would be an inconvenience rather than a crisis. If losing the car would mean losing your job, keep the cover.
  3. What are your local risks? Comprehensive is often cheap. If you park on the street in an area with high theft, or live where hail or floods are common, keeping comprehensive while dropping collision can be the better balance.
  4. Would raising the deductible get you most of the saving? Moving from a 500 to a 1,000 or 1,500 deductible can cut the cost substantially while still protecting you against a total loss.

A middle path: raise the deductible first

For many drivers the best step is not all or nothing. Ask your insurer for quotes at several deductible levels, then compare the saving with the extra risk you take on:

Collision and comprehensive cost 900 a year with a 500 deductible and 690 with a 1,500 deductible. Raising the deductible saves 210 a year and adds 1,000 to what you would pay in a claim. If you claim less often than once every five years or so, the higher deductible comes out ahead, and you are still protected if the car is written off or stolen.

What to keep whatever you decide

Do not cut liability limits to save money. State minimums are often low, and after a serious accident you are personally responsible for costs above your limits. Liability protects your savings, home and future income, which are worth far more than the car. Many drivers who drop collision on an older car use part of the saving to raise their liability limits or add uninsured motorist cover.

When to check again

Run the calculator once a year at renewal. The car's value falls every year, so the percentage creeps up even if the premium stays the same. A good time to drop the covers is when you pay off a car loan, because the lender's requirement ends then too.

Sources and further reading

  • Your policy declarations page, which shows the separate premium for each coverage.
  • Your state insurance department's minimum liability requirements and consumer guides.
  • Pricing guides such as Kelley Blue Book, Edmunds or NADA Guides for an estimate of your car's private-party value.
  • Your loan or lease contract, which states the insurance you are required to keep.

Common questions

Is liability-only insurance legal?

Yes. In almost every US state the legal requirement is liability cover, sometimes with personal injury protection or uninsured motorist cover. Collision and comprehensive are optional unless a lender or lessor requires them.

Can I keep comprehensive and drop collision?

Many insurers allow it. Comprehensive is usually much cheaper than collision and covers theft, fire, flood, hail, falling objects and animal strikes, so keeping it on an older car can be good value, especially if theft or weather is a real risk where you live.

What happens to my claims if I drop collision?

If you cause an accident, your liability cover still pays for the other driver's car and injuries. You pay to repair or replace your own car. If the other driver is at fault, you can still claim against their liability insurance.

Will dropping full coverage raise my price later?

Usually not, as long as you keep liability cover without a gap. A lapse in insurance is what tends to raise future prices.

This guide is general information, not personal financial, legal, insurance or mechanical advice. Rules, prices and specifications vary by state, country and vehicle, so check the details that apply to you and speak to a qualified professional about your situation.

Your next step

See how fast your car is losing value

Collision and comprehensive only ever pay out the car's current value. Our depreciation calculator estimates that value year by year.

Open the depreciation calculator