AUTOREPTBuying, insuring and running a car
LatestCar batteriesTyres: when to replaceDashboard warning lightsWhat's new →
Finance guide

Refinancing a Car Loan: When It Saves Money and When It Only Looks Like It Does

Refinancing replaces your current car loan with a new one, ideally at a lower rate. Done well, it can save hundreds or thousands. Done badly, it lowers the monthly payment while quietly raising what you pay overall. The difference is almost always the term.

Contents
  1. How refinancing works
  2. Compare total interest, not the payment
  3. Run your own numbers
  4. When refinancing usually makes sense
  5. When it usually does not
  6. Costs and paperwork to check
  7. How to refinance, step by step
  8. One more option: pay the old loan faster
  9. Sources and further reading
  10. Common questions

Key points

  • Refinancing saves money when the new rate is meaningfully lower and you do not stretch the repayment period much.
  • A lower monthly payment is not the same as a saving. Compare the total interest you will still pay under each option, after fees.
  • The best times to refinance are after your credit score has improved, after market rates have fallen, or if you accepted a marked-up dealer rate.
  • Check for prepayment penalties, title transfer fees and add-ons such as gap cover that may need to be cancelled or replaced.

How refinancing works

When you refinance, a new lender pays off your existing loan and you start repaying the new lender instead, at a new rate and over a new term. The lien on your car's title moves to the new lender. Nothing else about the car changes.

There are only two levers that change what you pay overall: the interest rate and the number of months you keep paying interest. A lower rate always helps. A longer term almost always hurts, because interest runs for longer. Most refinancing offers advertise the drop in monthly payment, which is driven by both levers at once, so it tells you very little on its own.

Compare total interest, not the payment

You owe 18,000 with 48 months left at 11% APR. Your payment is about 465 a month and you will pay about 4,330 in interest over the rest of the loan.

Offer A: 7% over 48 months. Payment about 431. Remaining interest about 2,690. Saving about 1,640 before fees.

Offer B: 7% over 72 months. Payment about 307, which looks far better. But remaining interest is about 4,100, so the saving shrinks to about 235 before fees, and you make payments for two more years, on a car that will be older and worth less.

Offer B "saves" 158 a month and almost nothing in total. Offer A saves 34 a month and over 1,600 in total.

Run your own numbers

Ask your lender for a payoff figure and use the months you have left on the loan. Enter the new offer's rate, term and any fees you would pay.

Car loan refinance calculator
Current payment-
New payment-
Total saving after fees-

Estimate only, assuming fixed rates and on-time payments. A negative saving means the new loan costs more overall, even if the payment is lower.

When refinancing usually makes sense

  • Your credit has improved. If your score has moved up a tier since you bought the car, for example after a year of on-time payments, you may now qualify for a noticeably lower rate.
  • You took the dealer's financing without shopping. Dealers can add a markup to the rate the lender offers. A loan arranged at the dealership is often the easiest to beat.
  • Market rates have fallen since you took out the loan.
  • You want to remove a co-signer and qualify on your own.
  • You are early in the loan. Interest is front-loaded, so the earlier you refinance, the more there is to save.

When it usually does not

  • You have less than a year or so left. Most of the interest has already been paid.
  • The only way to get a lower payment is a much longer term.
  • Fees, or a prepayment penalty on the current loan, eat most of the saving.
  • You owe much more than the car is worth and the new lender would require a large payment to approve you.

Costs and paperwork to check

Item What to look for
Prepayment penalty Read the current contract. Many car loans have none, but check before you apply.
Title and lien transfer fee Charged by your state motor vehicle agency to record the new lender. Usually modest.
Lender fees Some lenders charge an origination or processing fee. Include it in the calculator.
Gap cover and add-ons If you bought gap protection or a service contract through the old loan, ask whether it ends at payoff and whether you are owed a pro-rated refund. Arrange replacement gap cover if you still need it.
Payment timing Keep paying the old loan until it shows as paid in full, so you never miss a payment during the switch.

How to refinance, step by step

  1. Get your numbers. Request a 10-day payoff statement from your current lender and check your credit report for errors.
  2. Check your car's value. Lenders compare the loan to the car's value. A pricing guide gives you an estimate.
  3. Get several quotes within a short window. Try at least one credit union, one bank and one online lender, and compare APR, term and fees.
  4. Run each offer through the calculator using the same months-left figure.
  5. Apply for the best one. You will usually need your driving licence, proof of income, proof of insurance, the vehicle identification number and the payoff statement.
  6. Confirm the payoff. The new lender pays the old one. Check that the old account closes with a zero balance and ask for written confirmation.
  7. Sort out add-ons and the title. Claim any refund for cancelled add-ons, arrange new gap cover if needed, and keep the paperwork showing the new lienholder.

One more option: pay the old loan faster

If refinancing does not save enough, you can still cut interest by paying a little extra each month, as long as your contract allows prepayment without penalty and the lender applies extra payments to principal. Even 50 extra a month shortens most loans by several months. Our auto loan financing guide has a calculator you can use to test the effect.

Sources and further reading

  • The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau's consumer guides to auto loans and refinancing, at consumerfinance.gov.
  • Your current loan contract and a payoff statement from your lender, which show the exact payoff amount and any prepayment terms.
  • Your state motor vehicle agency, for title and lien transfer fees.

Common questions

How soon can I refinance a car loan?

There is usually no legal minimum, but many lenders want to see the title transferred to the original lender and at least a few months of payments. Refinancing early in the loan saves the most interest because that is when most of the interest is charged.

Does refinancing hurt my credit score?

A new application usually triggers a hard inquiry, which can lower your score slightly for a short time. Credit scoring models generally treat several auto loan inquiries within a short shopping window as one, so compare offers within a couple of weeks.

Can I refinance if I owe more than the car is worth?

It is harder. Many lenders cap the loan at a percentage of the car's value. You may need to pay down the balance first, or look for lenders, often credit unions, that accept a higher loan-to-value ratio.

Should I refinance to a longer term to lower my payment?

Only if you genuinely need the cash flow, and with the understanding that it usually costs more overall. If you do, keep paying the old amount when you can, so the loan clears early.

This guide is general information, not personal financial, legal, insurance or mechanical advice. Rules, prices and specifications vary by state, country and vehicle, so check the details that apply to you and speak to a qualified professional about your situation.

Your next step

Check what you should be paying

Our auto loan guide explains how rates are set by credit tier and term, so you can tell whether an offer is competitive.

Read the auto loan guide